Health insurance in Singapore can be complex, with different types of coverage available. Two key types of health protection people often consider are Integrated Shield Plans (IPs) and Critical Illness (CI) Insurance. While they may seem similar at first glance, they serve different purposes. Understanding their differences will help you decide whether you need one, the other, or both.

Learn more: Health Insurance In Singapore >>

What Are Integrated Shield Plans?

Integrated Shield Plans (IPs) are hospitalisation insurance policies that enhance the coverage provided by MediShield Life, Singapore’s basic health insurance scheme. These plans are offered by private insurers and cover:

• Hospital bills for public and private hospitals
• Surgical procedures
• Certain pre- and post-hospitalisation treatments
• Selected outpatient treatments

Those who want higher coverage, including private hospital stays and overseas treatments, often turn to private insurance providers.

What Is Critical Illness (CI) Insurance?

Unlike IPs, Critical Illness (CI) Insurance does not cover hospitalisation bills directly. Instead, it provides a lump sum payout when the insured is diagnosed with one of the 37 severe-stage critical illnesses defined by the Life Insurance Association (LIA) Singapore.

What Can the Lump Sum Be Used For?

• Daily living expenses if the insured is unable to work
• Cost of long-term treatments that may not be covered by IPs
• Alternative treatments not included in standard hospitalisation insurance
• Caregiver and home care costs

1. What They Cover

• Integrated Shield Plans (IPs) focus on hospitalisation and treatment costs. If you are admitted to a hospital, your IP will cover the eligible medical bills based on your plan.
• Critical Illness (CI) Insurance, on the other hand, pays a lump sum upon diagnosis of a serious illness like cancer, stroke, or heart disease. This money can be used however you see fit—whether for medical treatments, living expenses, or alternative therapies.

2. Payout Structure

• IPs reimburse actual medical expenses. You need to submit your bills, and your insurer will cover the eligible amount.
• CI Insurance provides a fixed payout regardless of the treatment cost. This means that even if you don’t undergo medical treatment immediately, you still receive the lump sum payout.

3. Financial Protection Beyond Medical Bills

• IPs only help reduce medical costs by covering hospital stays, surgeries, and certain outpatient treatments. They do not provide direct financial support for daily expenses.
• CI Insurance helps with income replacement. Since a critical illness can prevent you from working, the lump sum payout can support you and your family financially during recovery.

4. Claim Conditions

• IPs only pay for covered medical treatments and usually require hospitalisation to be eligible for claims.
• CI Insurance pays upon confirmed diagnosis of a covered critical illness, even if hospitalisation is not required.

Do You Need Both?

The answer depends on your financial situation, health risks, and responsibilities.

If you only have an Integrated Shield Plan:

• You are covered for hospital bills but may struggle with lost income during long-term recovery.
• Out-of-pocket non-medical expenses, such as alternative treatments or caregiving costs, may not be covered.

If you only have Critical Illness Insurance:

• You will receive a lump sum but will still need to pay hospital bills out of pocket if you do not have an IP.
• A severe illness requiring long hospital stays or repeated surgeries can result in high medical costs that exceed your lump sum payout.

Having both an IP and CI Insurance ensures full financial protection—your hospital bills are covered while you have extra funds to manage lifestyle changes or lost income.