Health insurance and personal accident insurance serve different purposes, but many people assume they offer the same protection. While both provide financial support in times of medical need, they cover different types of risks. Understanding these differences is essential to making informed decisions about coverage.

Learn more: Health Insurance In Singapore >>

What Does Health Insurance Cover?

Health insurance is designed to cover medical expenses related to illnesses, diseases, and hospitalizations. In Singapore, policies like MediShield Life provide basic coverage for large hospital bills, but many people supplement this with Integrated Shield Plans (IPs) for better benefits. A comprehensive health insurance plan typically includes inpatient and outpatient treatments, specialist consultations, diagnostic tests, and sometimes even preventive care.

For example, private health insurance in Singapore can cover hospital stays in Class A or B1 wards, while MediShield Life primarily supports Class B2 and C wards in public hospitals.

What Does Personal Accident Insurance Cover?

Personal accident insurance focuses on injuries caused by accidents, whether minor or severe. It provides a lump sum payout for medical expenses, disability, or accidental death. Unlike health insurance, which reimburses costs based on treatments received, accident insurance pays a fixed sum depending on the severity of the injury.

For instance, if someone suffers a permanent disability due to a road accident, their personal accident policy may provide a lump sum payout based on the severity of the injury. Some policies also cover temporary disabilities, offering daily cash benefits for lost income during recovery. This type of insurance is especially beneficial for individuals in high-risk jobs or those who engage in extreme sports.

Key Differences Between Health and Personal Accident Insurance

One of the major differences between the two is how they handle claims. Health insurance covers ongoing medical treatments and hospitalization expenses, while personal accident insurance provides compensation specifically for accident-related injuries. 

Another distinction is in the payout structure—health insurance pays based on actual medical bills, whereas accident insurance pays a fixed amount based on policy terms.

Additionally, health insurance may cover pre-existing conditions, depending on the policy, while accident insurance does not. It only applies to unexpected incidents, making it a complementary policy rather than a replacement for health insurance.

Do You Need Both?

For most individuals, having both types of insurance provides better financial protection. Health insurance covers medical bills from illnesses and hospital stays, while accident insurance offers additional security for injuries that may not require hospitalization.

A common scenario is someone hospitalized due to an accident. Their health insurance will cover the hospital bills, but if they suffer a disability that affects their ability to work, their personal accident policy will provide additional financial support. This combination helps cover both medical costs and income loss.